Warren Buffett has underperformed the market 4 out of the last 5 years. Surprising for a value investor?
Warren Buffett is being compared to Michael Jordan.
Which wouldn't be that surprising, except this is Washington Wizards Michael Jordan we're talking about. Not the one who won all those championships.
Oracle of Omaha! Has it really come to this? Have the mighty so fallen that you now call to mind one of the most oft-cited metaphors of faded greatness?
The article I'm referring to was published Sunday in The New York Times, and then again today on Yahoo! Finance. There have also been numerous responses to it in Quartz and Slate, all of them posing pretty much the same question: Warren Buffett has underperformed basic index funds 4 out of the last 5 years–isn't that just a few too many to be considered a run of bad luck? The statistician behind the Times article says so.
If I may interject, however.
This past month our current bull market turned 5, making it the fifth longest in history. It seems counter-intuitive, but couldn't this account for Buffett's "underperformance"?
Possibly. Over a slightly longer time frame, for instance 10 years, Buffett's still beating the Dow and the S&P 500 pretty handily.
Click on the interactive chart to track Berkshire Hathaway and major indices over time.
He is often quoted as saying that one should always "be fearful when others are greedy."
In a bull market, the largest gainers are riskier assets: like unproven tech companies and lower-quality stocks that lost the most value during the recession. These are the very companies Buffett eschews.
Besides, since the analysis in the article only focuses on Berkshire Hathaway's (BRK) share-price, couldn't we just say that, outside of the 5 year time frame starting in 2008, Berkshire's shares traded at a larger premium than they did after a record-breaking, 30+% return on the stock market?
It stands to reason that investors are willing to pay more for a proven, cautious approach in bearish times. That's why they're called bearish.
The premise behind value investing has always meant sacrificing the possibility of short-term gains. But value investors claim to have the long view in mind. Are they right, or just arrogant and, in this case, missing out? Let us know what you think in the comments.
Click on the interactive chart to view data over time.
Here are six of Buffett's largest holdings based on the size of his stake in the company. Do you think they're market-beating picks or not?
Holds a 25.1% stake in the company worth $1,102,529,498.
Holds a 9.08% stake in the company worth $15,492,000,000.
3. Moody's Corp. (MCO, Earnings, Analysts, Financials): Provides credit ratings and related research, data, and analytical tools; risk management software; and quantitative credit risk measures, credit portfolio management solutions, and training services in the United States, Europe, the Middle East, and Africa. Market cap at $16.81B, most recent closing price at $77.97.
Holds a 11.54% stake in the company worth $1,937,317,666.
Holds a 17.65% stake in the company worth $2,577,425,124.
5. American Express Company (AXP, Earnings, Analysts, Financials): Provides charge and credit payment card products, and travel-related services worldwide. Market cap at $91.37B, most recent closing price at $86.60.
Holds a 14.31% stake in the company worth $13,070,358,447.
Holds a 23.39% stake in the company worth $1,207,638,624.
(List compiled by James Dennin. Monthly returns sourced from Zacks Investment Research. Buffett's holdings sourced from CNBC.)
Analyze These Ideas: Getting Started
- Read descriptions for all companies mentioned
- Access a performance overview for all stocks in the list
- Compare analyst ratings for the companies mentioned
- Compare analyst ratings to annual returns for stocks mentioned
- Real-Time Opinion: Scan the latest tweets about these companies (feed will open in a new window)
Dig Deeper: Access Company Snapshots, Charts, Filings
- USG Corporation(USG, Chart, Download SEC Filings)
- The Coca-Cola Company(KO, Chart, Download SEC Filings)
- Moody's Corp.(MCO, Chart, Download SEC Filings)
- DaVita, Inc.(DVA, Chart, Download SEC Filings)
- American Express Company(AXP, Chart, Download SEC Filings)
- Graham Holdings Company Common (GHC, Chart, Download SEC Filings)
© Kapitall, Inc. All rights reserved. Kapitall Wire is a division of Kapitall, Inc. Kapitall Generation, LLC is a wholly owned subsidiary of Kapitall, Inc.
Kapitall Wire offers free cutting edge investing ideas, intended for educational information purposes only. It should not be construed as an offer to buy or sell securities, or any other product or service provided by Kapitall Inc., and its affiliate companies.
Open a free account today get access to virtual cash portfolios, cutting-edge tools, stock market insights, and a live brokerage platform through our affiliated company, Kapitall Generation, LLC.